4 Weeks, Two Products: Edge Naturale vs Creme of Nature
Quick answer: Edge Naturale Follicle Enhancer and Creme of Nature Argan Oil Edge Control do different jobs. If your edges are thinning, broken, or slow-growing, Edge Naturale is built to support scalp health and circulation. Creme of Nature is a styling product that lays edges down. You may not need to choose one, but you do need to understand which one does what.
Why Are Women Searching This Comparison?
Because the beauty aisle is confusing. Both products sit in the edges section at Sally's or Target. Both have oils in the name or on the label. But one is a treatment and one is a styler. Women with thinning edges often grab whichever one has the best packaging and then wonder why nothing changed after a month.
Let's fix that.
What Does Each Product Actually Do?
| Feature | Edge Naturale Follicle Enhancer | Creme of Nature Argan Oil Edge Control |
|---|---|---|
| Primary purpose | Scalp treatment, follicle support | Styling, smoothing, lay-down |
| Key ingredients | Peppermint oil, argan oil, jojoba oil, coconut cream | Argan oil, castor oil, styling polymers, fragrance |
| How you use it | Massage into scalp and edges daily | Apply to hairline before styling |
| Hold factor | None, this is not a styler | Medium to firm hold |
| Scalp stimulation | Yes, peppermint increases circulation | No |
| Best for | Thinning, receding, or damaged edges | Styling healthy edges |
| Price range | Mid-range treatment | Budget-friendly styler |
Week 1: Setting Honest Expectations
If you start either product this week, here is what you will and will not see by Sunday.
With Creme of Nature Edge Control, your hairline will look neater immediately. That gel-like texture smooths down the baby hairs and gives you a clean finish in seconds. That is real, and it is genuinely useful. What it cannot do is feed a struggling follicle or change what is happening under the skin.
With Edge Naturale Follicle Enhancer, week one is about getting into a routine. Massaging the cream into your edges for two to three minutes daily increases blood flow to the area. Peppermint oil has been studied for this effect. A 2014 study published in Toxicological Research found that peppermint oil applied to the scalp showed promise in promoting hair growth in mice by increasing follicle depth and dermal thickness. Human studies are still limited, but the circulation mechanism is well understood. You will likely feel a tingle. You will not see new hair this week, and anyone who tells you otherwise is lying to you.
Week 2: What Changes First
By the second week with the Follicle Enhancer, most women notice their scalp feels less dry and irritated, especially around the hairline where lace glue, tight braids, or relaxers have done damage. The argan and jojoba oils are doing that work. Jojoba is structurally close to the scalp's own sebum, so it absorbs without sitting heavy or clogging pores.
Creme of Nature edge control in week two looks the same as week one. It performs consistently as a styler. That is its job, and it does it. But if your edges are thinning, consistent use of a firm-hold gel-type product without proper scalp care underneath can actually keep tension on already fragile hair. Apply it too heavy or too often and you may be adding stress to a hairline that needs rest.
Week 3: The Scalp-First Principle
This is where a veteran stylist will tell you something the product labels won't. Healthy edges grow from a healthy scalp. Full stop. No styler, no matter how many oils are listed on the back, can reverse traction alopecia or postpartum shedding. The American Academy of Dermatology notes that traction alopecia caught early is often reversible, but it requires removing the source of tension and giving the follicle a chance to recover.
Week three is when women using the Follicle Enhancer with consistent daily massage sometimes start seeing very fine new growth at the hairline. Not always. Depends on how long the thinning has been going on, overall health, stress levels, and whether the source of damage is still happening. If you are still wearing a tight sew-in every day and applying a treatment every night, you are fighting yourself.
Week three with Creme of Nature is still fine for styling. Use it to finish a look. Just do not use it as a substitute for treatment.
Week 4: What the Mirror Shows You
After four weeks of daily scalp massage with a treatment like Edge Naturale, many women report seeing baby hairs filling in, a softer texture along the hairline, and less visible scalp through the edges. These are signs the follicles are responding. Results vary, and they depend on the type and stage of hair loss. For significant or long-standing loss, a board-certified dermatologist should be part of the picture.
After four weeks of Creme of Nature Edge Control used correctly, your style still looks good and your edges still look laid. That is not nothing. But if thinning was your concern on day one, it is still your concern on day 28.
Can You Use Both at the Same Time?
Yes, and honestly that is often the right answer. The routine looks like this:
- Massage Edge Naturale Follicle Enhancer into your scalp and edges on clean, damp hair. Let it absorb for a few minutes.
- Style your hair as usual.
- Apply Creme of Nature Edge Control only to smooth the surface hair when you are doing a finished style.
- Give your hairline at least two or three days a week with no hold product at all. Let the scalp breathe.
Layering a treatment underneath and a styler on top is not double work. It is scalp care first, style second. That order matters.
Who Should Skip Creme of Nature for Edges?
If your edges are so thin you can see scalp clearly, if they are not growing back after a protective style is taken down, or if you have been diagnosed with traction alopecia, an edge control gel should not be your primary product right now. Your priority is reducing tension, supporting circulation, and giving damaged follicles a rest. Style matters. But hair matters more.
The Honest Bottom Line
Creme of Nature Argan Oil Edge Control is a solid, affordable styler. It is not a treatment. Edge Naturale Follicle Enhancer is a treatment. It is not a styler. They are not competing for the same job, and comparing them as if they are will leave you frustrated with both.
If your edges are thinning, start with the treatment. Add the styler when the style calls for it. And give it real time, not four days.
FAQs
Does Creme of Nature Argan Oil actually help edges grow back?
No, not on its own. Creme of Nature Edge Control is a styling product. It contains some nourishing oils, but its formula is designed to hold and smooth hair, not to stimulate follicles or support regrowth. If your edges are thinning, you need a dedicated scalp treatment, not a styler.
How long does Edge Naturale take to show results on thinning edges?
Most women who use it consistently, meaning daily massage for at least four to six weeks, start noticing changes in scalp texture and early baby hair growth in that window. Significant regrowth from traction alopecia or postpartum shedding can take several months. Anyone promising results in a week is overpromising.
Is peppermint oil safe to put on your hairline every day?
For most people, yes. Peppermint oil diluted in a carrier like jojoba or coconut oil, which is how it appears in Edge Naturale, is generally well tolerated. You will feel a tingle. If you experience burning, redness, or irritation, stop use and see a dermatologist. Those with sensitive skin should patch test first.
Can edge control products cause thinning edges?
They can contribute, especially if applied heavily and repeatedly with tension, like slicking edges tightly under a scarf or bonnet every night, or using them on top of already stressed follicles. The hold in gel-type products is not inherently damaging, but the application habits around them sometimes are. Tight wrapping, pulling, and friction over time add up.
What ingredients should I look for in an edges treatment versus an edge styler?
For a treatment, look for scalp-active ingredients like peppermint oil, rosemary oil, biotin, castor oil, or jojoba, applied directly to the scalp with massage. For a styler, hold agents, smoothing polymers, and lightweight oils like argan are appropriate. If the first three ingredients in a product are holding agents, it is a styler regardless of what the marketing says.
I have traction alopecia. Which product should I use?
A scalp treatment focused on reducing inflammation and supporting circulation, used alongside genuinely looser protective styles or a break from tension altogether. The American Academy of Dermatology says early-stage traction alopecia can be reversible if the tension source is removed. A dermatologist can confirm your stage and whether additional treatment like topical minoxidil is appropriate.
This article is for education and is not medical advice. If you are worried about hair loss, see a board-certified dermatologist. These statements have not been evaluated by the FDA. Edge Naturale products are not intended to diagnose, treat, cure, or prevent any disease.